« Homeschooling: A Panel Discussion | Main | Groovy »
May 05, 2006
Cover Me
So I was reading reviews of a new book, Trading Places by Claudia Mills. The reviews are great, and I was all like, “I sooooo want to read that.”
Then I saw the cover:

And I didn’t want to read the book anymore.
I mean, *what’s* going on there? It’s busy, the children's faces look really weird, and the colors…. Well.
As an author and a librarian, I find this sort of thing disturbing. This author, no doubt, put her heart and soul into writing this book, she probably got no say in the cover, and that cover ain’t gonna sell. Maybe she’ll get lucky and the book will win an award or something, but that’s a long shot.
In sharp contrast, let’s examine the cover of another book:

The colors are bright and pretty. There are flowers, cool shoes, and a bra. The fonts are fun. As a whole, it says, “Read me, Adrienne! I’m fun!” (I am, and it is.)
We all know we aren’t supposed to judge a book by its cover, but, you know, people do. And people who know more about this than I do are paid to create these things, which leaves me wondering how covers like Trading Places happen. And I’m still left with the dilemma of whether or not to buy the book. On the one hand, it looks good. On the other, I imagine it sitting there lonely on the shelf never getting checked out because very few children would get past a cover that bad.
Thoughts from cyberspace?
Posted by adrienne at May 5, 2006 06:53 AM
Comments
I say close your eyes and go for it...chances are if you don't you will miss out on some good reading.(hopefully you will remember to open your eyes...lol...) My cat has a "poop" mark on her face that looks terrible, but I still love her!!! lol...
It does look bad though...
Posted by: Kristen at May 5, 2006 07:31 AM
Ah, but how many pages does it have? Sadly, some kids never get past a certain point there, either. Hey, if you really don't like the cover...you can just design your own and cover the bad cover. We used to do that in our school library...
Posted by: Elizabeth at May 5, 2006 08:24 AM
This is why I think you should become a librarian, Elizabeth. :) That's a great thought! When I come across good books that aren't getting the attention they deserve, I always think it's part of my job to try to bring attention to them -- because who else will? This would be an interesting thing to try, although I could imagine some of my fellow librarians having heart attacks....
Posted by: adrienne at May 5, 2006 09:10 AM
Ah, but I LIKE it. It's moody and strange. Great for a grown-up book, but not for a kid book, you are right...
Posted by: Heidi at May 5, 2006 10:18 AM
It really is about the cover, no matter what age group a book is for. If an adult book doesn't even have a mildly interesting cover or title, it won't get picked up. For teens/children, all I can think of is "Lizzie Bright and the Buckminster Boy", which has an awful cover, but is an award winner. As soon as I saw it, I knew it was doomed to shelf sit. I have reviewed a few books with covers that made a book look like it was already 20 years old, and have mentioned that in my review so that the librarians will know it probably won't circulate. A, maybe you should write an open letter to the publishers about cover art, too. This particular cover doesn't seem *so* bad, though - it might circulate if you can get one kid to read it and tell all of his or her friends how great it is. Word of mouth can do wonders.
Posted by: Olivia at May 5, 2006 10:35 AM
Go with the content.It isn't fair to the author to do otherwise.Really.And if it sits because of its cover,set it up in a cool little book of the week thing or something to draw attention to it&get word of mouth going:-)Sorry this may sound harsh--I'm just in a hurry!Love to all:-)
Posted by: momster at May 5, 2006 12:04 PM
What scares me off more than the cover is the apparent tired old children's book and movie theme of trading places, bodies, lifestyles, etc. I noticed at about age 10 that there was a pattern that a "Freaky Friday" -type movie or after school special came out about every two years, and that pattern has kept up steadily ever since. If this book is somehow different than the hundreds of books/movies/TV on the topic of people becoming someone else for a while and experiencing their life and both of them growing and becoming more tolerant of each other in the process, then that is not conveyed by the cover. But the cover still is ugly, busy, and would make me want to shove it back into the shelf.
Posted by: chuck at May 5, 2006 12:09 PM
This is a total sidetrack, but have I mentioned lately how much work it is to write a book? Particularly when your cat keeps thinking it's a good idea to lay down on your notes and/or keyboard? And you have to move her? Repeatedly? And the articles you're reading are riddled with factual errors?
Yeah.
Not to mention the fact I'm getting hungry. I drank a latte AND ate some grapes for breakfast. Shouldn't that keep me going longer than this?
Please keep commenting. It's a very welcome diversion.
Posted by: adrienne at May 5, 2006 12:39 PM
Oh, yeah, and now freaking InfoTrac decided to have "technical difficulties."
Whatever.
Posted by: adrienne at May 5, 2006 12:59 PM
The book cover is awful. I usually judge books by their covers and actually I love the SmartBitches blog because they make fun of book covers.
Writing is a a lot of work, especially when you're working.
Posted by: tonderdo at May 7, 2006 08:04 PM
Of course, writing mostly just looks like a lot of sitting at the computer, periodically trying to convince your cat that it would be a good idea to stop lying on the keyboard and your notes.
Posted by: adrienne at May 7, 2006 08:39 PM